Blog
Light to Dark or Dark to Light / Claire's Questions Part 6

Occasionally I get asked questions about my painting process. One inquiry in particular came at a time during the pandemic when I had a lot of time to think about and a lot of her questions to think about. I found myself writing quite a long response, and that has now become this series of blog posts where I answer "Claire's Questions."
This week we are talking about painting light to dark vs dark to light.
Claire's Question:
"How do you process in terms of layers / light to dark or dark to light? (I saw your blog post"work in progress" and that was already very interesting but was wondering about your water-color technique."

My process:
First I analyze my reference photos for potential, or draw something out and then make a value sketch out of it. Then I draw the important elements as careful shapes on the watercolor paper with a pencil. For the less important elements, like background trees, rocks, cattle or clouds, I may mark their general size, shape and position but only if seems necessary.
Then I start painting the most important element, probably the cowboy’s face and hat or the horse’s head, and then I work out from there. These are the elements I’m most likely to mess up and if they come out ugly, or overworked I don’t have so much time invested that I can’t throw it away and start over. Anyway if the figures are okay, I just continue out from there and finally on into the background. The sky is usually last.
My shape by shape approach allows a lot of shapes to be painted once and not touched again. However, many areas might be combined in a big wash that includes many smaller shapes. It’s usually a light color, and then has other shapes within, getting another wash over them later. A typical example might be a man’s shirt. The entire shirt might be a light pink wash, leaving the white paper where the lightest areas will be. I often use a hair dryer to speed the drying process. Then the medium value wrinkles might get a more intense red over the pink, shape by shape. Then the darkest value areas and deep shadows might get dark red blending to purple and possibly blending to black.

"Buffalo Man"
If the darkest part of the shirt blends into the darkest part of his pants, or the darkest part of the horse or the darkest part of something else next to him, I might blend into the darkness of the new area’s color. I have this personal desire for some edges to be crisp, one color to the next, some of the most important edges to be crisp black to white, and some edges to be soft and blend, and some to be not edges at all. In our example the shirt could become the horse with no edge if the deepest shadow blended from red to burnt sienna and the part of the horse next to the shirt would get burnt sienna. I love that effect and feel warm inside, but if I do it right no one else would notice or care. But that’s just me. I’m not suggesting it.
By the way, I do it in oil painting, too. Yesterday I amused myself letting a yellow sky blend into the back of a palomino horse. His neck and hips are defined against the sky and the viewers mind puts it all together. You see it as a horse and your mind sees the whole horse even though I didn’t define his back. It is my own private little entertainment although no one will notice.
...I have a few more thoughts on the subject of light to dark vs dark to light but I'm running out of room. To be continued in Part 6B HERE.
2 Responses to Light to Dark or Dark to Light / Claire's Questions Part 6
Leave a Comment